Pickled Peppers

If Peter Piper picked a peck of pickled peppers, this would be the pickled peppers Peter Piper would pick!

Tommy is addicted to – YES, addicted to – pickled peppers on his sandwiches. He goes through at least a jar a week. That really adds up after a while!

I have been dying to try my hand at pickles, pickled beets, dilly beans, SOMETHING! I want to can and preserve and see jars lining my pantry shelves.

The problem? I AM A CHICKEN! What if I get too overwhelmed? What if the jars EXPLODE in the water bath? What if after the water bath the tops don’t vacuum close? What if, after all of this work and horrors, whatever I put up tastes YUCKY!?

This sort of stuff keeps me up nights.

And then I happened upon the wonderful blog Seasoned to Taste! What did she make? Pickled peppers! It was fate!  Come on, girl, put on your big girl pants and give it a try! What’s the worst that happens? They’re terrible and you throw them out!

So off I went  – I bought peppers. I bought jars. Shaking in my boots, I started –

  • 3 C sliced peppers
  • 3 C white vinegar
  • 1 C water
  • 3 cloves garlic, crushed


NOTE: I used Italian frying peppers. And, although Seasoned to Taste used hot peppers, for my first try I decided to stay sweet.

Sanitize jars and lids. Once clean, remove without touching insides to cool on a clean towel.

NOTE: Okay. I am a canning dunce. I washed the jars and lids in my dishwasher – which doesn’t have a sanitize button, but does have a super hot wash and dry cycle. Also, I waited to begin the dishwasher until I was absolutely ready to start. I cut up the pepper first, started the wash, put the water up to boil for the water bath.

Set two large stainless steel (or non-aluminum) pots on the stove, one filled with enough water to submerge jars. Heat water-filled pot.

In second pot, combine vinegar, water and garlic. Bring to boil over medium-high heat. Reduce heat and boil for 5 min. Discard garlic.

Pack peppers into sanitized jars and ladle hot pickling liquid in, leaving 1/2 inch head space. Tap to remove air bubbles, wipe rim. Center lid on jar and tighten.

NOTE: This centering and tightening had me completely a little nuts. Is the lid on straight? Wait, that rim feels crooked.  

Place jars in canning pot of water, bring to a boil, cover and process 10 min. Remove lid, wait 5 min. then remove jars and cool. Once cooled, you will feel that the seal has snapped shut. Store, or open and eat!

NOTE: I placed a dishcloth on the bottom of the pot so the jars wouldn’t clank around as much. Of course, I didn’t read the directions properly and put the jars in water already boiling! My second batch I re-read and slapped myself in the forehead and did it the right way! Now, my question is: “Remove lid and wait 5 minutes.”  Is that 5 minutes lid off, heat on or 5 minutes lid off, heat off? See why pickling drives me insane!?

I have now done this twice. Once totally sweet, the second with a hot chili involved. They’re sitting on a shelf. The boy walks by and stares at them. A few more days and he can have at ’em!

By the way, when you first take them out of the water, the lids are tight. Then suddenly they are loose! Then I go in a panic and walk away disgusted. Then I come back when the jars are much cooler and like magic the lids are tight and sealed!

Now, how easy was that? What were you all so worried about?

13 Responses

  1. you’re too funny

  2. Canning is a process of learning. You’re doing great!

  3. These look great! I am going to need to can some peppers myself this weekend, I will have to give your recipe a try. And canning is definitely a learning process, I am still learning myself.

  4. I made and posted about my first pickled vegetables a few months ago. I too have a fear of pickling. I took the easy way out and pickled green beans to be eaten immediately. So I skipped the canning pot step. Now I may just have to try it…

    • Silly isn’t it! And then you try it and there’s nothing to be afraid of. Well, at least not of pickled peppers! Off to bread and butter pickles!

  5. The jars will not explode. Oh you could wear goggles, seriously. I think these would be amazing on a sandwich too.

  6. What a fun read. I enjoyed angsting with you over your pickling of the peppers. I have never even had an inkling that I should pickle anything myself…and you think YOU are a scaredy cat! Looks delish!

  7. well done! I do not go to all that trouble when canning and I must say I have never had a problem with not doing the water bath stage 🙂

  8. I love this post. I was exactly this nervous the first time I used a hto water bath. Canning is fun once you get going with it!

  9. I really need to buckle down and learn to can! These pickled peppers look delicious 🙂

Leave a Reply to Nuts about Food Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s